Cookies
We offer a wide variety of traditional, Italian, specialty & custom cookies. Order online with our easy-to-use form submission or stop by any of our locations to see our daily, fresh-baked selection!
Cookies Categories:
Italian Cookies
Our Italian cookies are ALWAYS a hit (especially our crowd favorite macaroon cookies)! We offer a HUGE selection of our 'staple" flavors and always add in delicious seasonal flavors that will surely get you in the seasonal spirt. Come on in and see for yourself our always fresh assortment in store!
Italian Cookies
Biscotti Cookies
Our Italian cookies are homemade with the best ingredients and available in a variety of shapes and sizes. Options: Chocolate, Orange Cinnamon, Cappuccino, Anise, Quasamali and Sesame. Please note any special requests/custom cookie assortment.
per lb
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Hazelnut Ladyfingers
Crunchy, buttery cookie sandwiched with creamy Nutella filling & topped with sprinkles.
per pound
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Italian Rainbow Cookies
Almond flavored cake layered with subtle raspberry, coated in chocolate.
per lb
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Macaroon Cookies
Our Italian cookies are homemade with the best ingredients and available in a variety of shapes and sizes. Options: Cherry, Plain, Almond, Pistachio or Chocolate Dipped Coconut. Please note any special request/custom cookie assortment.
per lb
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Melt-Away Cookies
Buttery shortbread cookie covered in sweet powdered sugar.
per lb
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Raspberry Shortbread Cookies
Buttery shortbread cookie with dollop of raspberry preserve topped with powdered sugar.
per lb
$16.99
Italian Cookies
Sprinkle Butter Cookies
Yellow Sprinkle or Chocolate Sprinkle
per lb
$12.99
Italian Cookies
Sugar-Free Cookies
Priced by weight. Choice of: Raspberry Pockets, Chocolate Chip, Marble Swirl & Orange Fan w/ Chocolate. Assortment may vary with season & store.
per lb
$16.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Presentation is key when hosting or attending any function/party. Pick up one of our packaged items today that will be sure to catch anyones eye!
Packaged Cookie Items
Anise Pizzelle
per pack
$6.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Chocolate Pizzelle
per pack
$6.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Lemon Pizzelle
per pack
$6.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Mini Cookie Pack
We take the quintessential American recipe for Tollhouse Cookies and add a Fratelli's spin to it for cookies that are out of this world delicious! Assortment: Chocolate Chip, M&M & Sprinkle. Please note any special requests/custom cookie assortment.
per 18 cookies
$8.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Soft Biscotti
Choice of Anise or Lemon with icing
1 dozen per pack
dozen
$6.99
Packaged Cookie Items
Vanilla Pizzelle
per pack
$6.99
Signature Cookies
Our signature cookies are baked fresh daily and are the perfect go-to item for any party - loved by kids & adults, it's a win, win! Order ahead, they go fast!
Signature Cookies
Large Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our famous & out-of-this-world, scratch recipe! Chewy, flavorful & loaded with chocolate chips - satisfaction guaranteed!
each
$1.25
per dzn
$13.75
Signature Cookies
Large M&M Cookies
We take the quintessential American recipe for Tollhouse Cookies and add a Fratelli's spin to it for cookies that out of this world delicious
each
$1.25
per dzn
$13.75
Signature Cookies
Large Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Chewy, spiced oatmeal cookie with sweet raisins.
each
$1.25
per dzn
$13.75
Signature Cookies
Large Sprinkle Cookies
We take the quintessential American recipe for Tollhouse Cookies and add a Fratelli's spin to it for cookies that out of this world delicious!
each
$1.25
per dzn
$13.75
Signature Cookies
Mini Cookies
Mini Cookies are the perfect option for any gathering, not too big or small! Choice of chocolate chip, M&M, oatmeal raisin or sprinkle! Looking for trayed cookies? Check out our trayed mini cookies!
per dzn
$6.99
Signature Cookies
Shortbread Filled Cookies - Chocolate
Shortbread flavored cookie stuffed with gooey Nutella chocolate.
each
$2.25
Signature Cookies
Shortbread Filled Cookies - Raspberry
Shortbread flavored cookie stuffed with refreshing, homemade raspberry preserve, topped with powdered sugar.
each
$2.25
Signature Cookies
XL Molasses Cookie
Soft & chewy molasses flavored cookie, sprinkled with granulated sugar.
each
$2.50
Signature Cookies
XL Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Soft & chewy peanut butter cookie with large peanut butter chunks!
each
$2.50
Signature Cookies
XL Sugar Cookies
XL sugar cookies topped with colored granulated sugar.
each
$2.25
Signature Cookies
XL White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie
each
$2.50
Trayed Cookie Items
Our cookie trays are the perfect display for any party! Designed to “WOW” in look AND taste!
Trayed Cookie Items
Italian Cookie Trays
Italian cookie tray assortment consists of a majority of Macaroons (Plain, Cherry, Almond, Pistachio & Chocolate Coconut) and Butter Cookies (Yellow Sprinkle & Chocolate Sprinkle). We also add a handful of mixed Biscottis and a smaller sampling of our other specialty/seasonal cookies which may include: Raspberry Shortbread, Snowball Melt Away, Italian Rainbow, Peanut Butter Crunch, Apricot Pocket, etc.
**Assortment is subject to vary by location.
Please note any special requests/custom cookie assortment and we will do our best to accommodate.
**Assortment is subject to vary by location.
Please note any special requests/custom cookie assortment and we will do our best to accommodate.
3lb tray
$54.00
5lb tray
$90.00
Trayed Cookie Items
Large Cookie Platter
2 dozen assorted cookies. Flavor choices: Chocolate Chip, M&M, Sprinkle, Sugar, Oatmeal Raisin.
each tray
$31.99
Trayed Cookie Items
Mini Cookie Platters
Choice of 3, 4 or 8 dozen trayed mini cookies with your choice of flavors: chocolate chip, M&M, oatmeal raisin or sprinkle.
per 3 dozen
$21.99
per 4 dozen
$29.99
per 8 dozen
$59.99